This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
close
";s:4:"text";s:28575:"Memorial contributions may be forwarded to SPCA of Marion County, 11100 SW 93rd St Rd, Suite 10-115, Ocala, FL 34481, https://spcaofmarioncounty.weebly.com/donations.html. When Barack Obama decided in January that he would run for . Select from premium Susan Landau of the highest quality. Topics outside of politics are also fair game including his Jewish identity. David became a political columnist as well as the City Hall Bureau Chief for the paper. They were busy and happy. 2023 CURE Epilepsy. The tensions certainly contributed to a rift with the Orthodox community, which overwhelmingly backed Trump in November. After graduating from the University of Chicago, where he studied political science, Axelrod spent nearly eight years as a political reporter for the Chicago Tribune . On the night that the Affordable Care Act finally passed, he went into his office, closed the door and sobbed, as he recounted in his 2015 memoir, Believer: My Forty Years in Politics.. I thought she was dead. David and his team have been incredibly generous with sharing their contacts, said Meredith Daw, executive director of the universitys career center. After Obama's election, Axelrod was appointed as Senior Advisor to the President. It was a failure. Your email address will not be published. Axelrod is 67 years old as of 2022. . [9], From 1999 until 2010, she specialized in internet security at Sun Microsystems. He was also active in the Obama campaign, serving as the chief strategist and media advisor for Obama. Sign up to receive the latest updates from U.S News & World Report and our trusted partners and sponsors. Susan Landau works at the intersection of cybersecurity, national security, law, and policy. [6], Landau is an alumna of Bronx Science and the Hampshire College Summer Studies in Mathematics. On January 28, 2011, he resigned from his position as White House senior advisor. Also known as Susn R Landau, Susan Strugats. Obviously, the majority opinion in this room doesnt seem to be on my side, but you and I even though we come from different sides of the aisle can have a civil conversation in front of a civil audience and air some significant issues for our country without having people mauled or beaten or harassed.. Published by at December 18, 2021. The house has4 baths, quarter-sawn solid oak floors,premium surround sound, a wet bar, automaticshades in every room, and other features in it. Axelrod stands at an average height of 6 feet 1 inch. I didnt hear from Lauren for the rest of the night. They didn't know that two-thirds of those diagnosed with epilepsy had seizures defined as idiopathic, of unexplained origin, as would be the case with Lauren. With Adam Schiff, for example, the host talked, as expected, about the Russia probe that has put the Los Angeles Democrat in the national spotlight. Susan Landau had married David Axelrod in 1979, and they lived in Chicago, where Susanpursued an MBA at the University of Chicago and David worked as a political reporter for theChicago Tribune . She is known as Lauren Axelrod and was diagnosed with epilepsy at the . Finally, I thought, 'Well, I can cry forever, or I can try to make a change.' At the University of Chicago, David established a bipartisan Institute of Political in January 2013. Since then, CURE Epilepsy has raised over $90 million to fund more than 280 research grants around the world. Susan Landau, whom he married in 1979. (He later would become chief strategist for Barack Obama's Presidential campaign and now is a senior White House adviser.) They got married in 1979 and had their first child, a daughter, in June 1981. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. In shock, I picked her up, and she went into a seizure arms extended, eyes rolling back in her head. Susan Axelrod is the Founder of CURE Epilepsy. Lauren was diagnosed with epilepsy at just seven months of age. We and our partners use cookies to Store and/or access information on a device. Resides in Roslyn Heights, NY. They agreed that no federal agency or private foundation was acting with the sense of urgency they felt, leaving 3 million American families to suffer in near-silence. David has authored several books, worked for CNN, was an adjunct professor, is director of the Bipartisan Institute of Politics, and has sold two homes, one for $1.65m and the other for $2.5m. Susan began to meet other parents living through similar hells. David Axelrod (Obama's guys) Susan Landau Axelrod (David's wife and founder of CURE} William Charles "Bill" Ayers (American elementary education theorist) Cyrus Leroy Baldridge (artist, U of C grad) . The connections that Axelrod has made throughout his life, so valuable for booking Washington insiders, have also been a boon to students, providing 225 paid internships with government agencies, think tanks and public policy organizations. Later, veterans back from Iraq with seizures caused by traumatic brain injuries demanded answers, too. Nothing can match the anguish of the mom of a chronically ill child, David says, but Susan turned that anguish into action. The couple hosted a private ceremony in 1979 with just their closest friends, family, and loved ones on the guest list. Yes, he is a loving husband to his beautiful and also caring wife Susan Landau. 3. Susan is survived by her loving children Marc (Jeanne) Axelrod, Sara (Paul) Axelrod Janousek, and Jon (Rhonda) Axelrod; cherished grandchildren Justin Imrie, Bailey (Adam) Pastva, Molly Imrie (Damaso Bautista), and Chase Axelrod (Alexyss Guy); and beloved great-grandchildren Kristopher, Victoria, Emilia, Dylan, Callen. American troops targeted, and he still has nothing to say., What is it about @realDonaldTrump and Russia? At one point or another, Axelrod worked for five of the eight candidates for 2008 Democratic presidential nominee, including Obama's main rivals, John Edwards and Hillary Clinton. He says those influences shaped him into a life-long champion of the underdog and a fervent believer in government as an engine of upward mobility. Susan Patricia Landau, 71. Susan has served on the National Advisory Neurological Disorders and Stroke Council as well as the Epilepsy Research Programmatic Panel for the Congressionally Directed Medical Research Program. His life has been a series of political campaigns where he did his best to bring each candidate he represented to their desired position. 4. He started working for the Chicago Tribune immediately following his graduation and got married two years later. She was born on February 14, 1948 to parents Louis and Thelma (nee Litt) Schuman in Far Rockaway, New York. (The Israeli prime minister even called Axelrod and former chief of staff Rahm Emanuel self-hating Jews). She then graduated with an A.B. Exhausted, Susan fought on toward her MBA; David became a political consultant. His mother, Myril, was a journalist for the left-oriented 1940s magazine PM , and his father, Joseph, was a ballplayer turned psychologist. He is survived by two daughters, Susan Landau Axelrod, LAB'70, MBA'82, and Kay Landau Fricke, LAB'77; a brother, William M. Landau, AA'43; five grandchildren; and a great-granddaughter. from Hampshire College and pursued graduate study at NYU's . In November of 2008, David declared as a Senior Advisor to the administration of Obama. [18] In 2012, Landau won the Surveillance Studies Network Book Prize for her book Surveillance or Security? Her family lived around the Bronx area where she grew up and later got an education from. We didn't realize that this would define her whole life, that she would have thousands of these afterward, that they would eat away at her brain.. [2][8], In 20102011, she was a Fellow at the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study at Harvard, where she investigated issues involving security of government systems, and their privacy and policy implications. No medicine relieved the baby. They are skeptical, but not cynical, and theyre determined to achieve a better future. David Axelrod married his wife, Susan Landau, in 1979, two years after they both graduated from college. She was brought into the world on June 3, 1954, in New York, the USA. The Obama administration gave substantial credit to this report's analysis when it announced that it would not pursue exceptional access to phone data. David Axelrod's better half Susan Landau potentially has a net worth of more than $5 million to $10 million yet the . The couple has three children together namely; Lauren, Michael, and Ethan. susan landau axelrod. They didn't know that seizures were the body's manifestation of abnormal electrical activity in the brain or that the excessive neuronal activity could cause brain damage. Over the past 200 episodes, Axelrods most popular guest has been Obama, who chose this forum to break his silence on the new administration. Susan Landau was born on 3 June, 1954 in New York, United States, is an American mathematician and engineer. In the morning, I found her gray and limp in her crib. [11], In 1972, her project on odd perfect numbers won a finalist position in the Westinghouse Science Talent Search. We hardly knew who she was, Susan says. The couple met at the University where Susan was a business student. He enjoyed working there, but he left so that he can participate in Senator Paul Simons Campaign as his communications director. [15][16] She has been a fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science since 1999,[17] and in 2011 she was inducted as a Fellow of the Association for Computing Machinery. She worked for Lee Fisher and Eric Fingerhut, and was also a grant writer. Her videos are uplifting, fun and she is as real as it gets." Susan is a free spirit who found her own deeply resonant work as a Personal . American troops targeted and he still has nothing to say. But, later, they decreased the price andlisted it for$2.95 millionin March 2019. The Axelrods' daughter Lauren, one of three children, lives in a group home after a lifetime of seizures damaged her brain. The couple has three children together namely; Lauren, Michael, and Ethan. President Obamas win is largely attributed to Davids approach on the campaign trail. It's too late for us, so we committed ourselves to the hope that we can protect future generations from having their lives defined and devastated by this disorder.. Axelrod and his staff of 12 are hoping to accomplish those lofty goals by creating an open environment where students are exposed to a wide range of viewpoints a rarity in these times, Republican senator Tom Cotton of Arkansas acknowledged. She has briefed Congress on a variety of issues, including digital rights management and security and privacy of digital identity systems. It becomes more and more evident that it won't be just the doctors, researchers, and scientists pushing the field forward. David M. Axelrod (born February 22, 1955) is an American political operative and analyst. In fact, she was key to encouraging the National Institutes of Health to hold its first conference on curing epilepsy. This couple is blessed with three children named Lauren, Michael , and Ethan.His first child named Lauren was diagnosed with epilepsy at seven months of age.there is no information about her affairs in social sites. "For many many reasons, this disease has been really kept in the dark ages," said Susan. David Axelrod married to Susan Landau, and they married in 1979.The couple has three children together. They have also lived in Merrick, NY and . The Axelrods' daughter, Lauren, lives in a group home after a lifetime of seizures led to permanent brain damage. Therefore, David is 66 years old. The designer likewise has a calculation that she created called Landau's calculation. As you wouldnt expect from someone that rose all the way to the top, David attended a public school. Susan Landau, whom he married in 1979. Unfortunately for David, his next attempt at gaining a candidate for the presidency in 2004 resulted in another failure. Things would be better for me if I wouldn't have seizures, she says. David Axelrod, a senior adviser to the former president from 2009 until 2011, is selling his apartment. For more stories about families and the health challenges their children face, visit Parade.com. Axelrod is married to Susan Landau, the daughter of research doctor Richard L. Landau. His parents divorced when he was eight years old, and his father died in 1977 after suffering from severe clinical depression and committing suicide. Here is her story. The founding chair of Citizens United for Research in Epilepsy (CURE) has a deeply personal stake in the organization's mission. Subscriber | Log out | Manage Account Log . Family will receive friends for visitation on Sunday, September 11, 2022 from 10:00 until 11:00 am at Busch Funeral Home 114 Second St, Elyria, OH 44035. [19], Landau gave testimony in the FBIApple encryption dispute between 2015 and 2016. Little is known about how this impacted David, but we do know that he remained motivated to succeed. Signup for our Hollywood and pop culture newsletter. He worked for eight years old and covered local, state, and national politics. Michael Thrasher | Mar 29, 2018. Related:Poppy Harlow CNN Salary, Husband Cancer, Height, Real Name, Net worth. She was also the Local Director of Handgun Control Federation, and later the Director of the Department of Senior and Adult Services for Cuyahoga County. The first day we started Lauren on the medication, Susan says, her seizures subsided. . His father was also dealing with depression that no one was aware of and ended up committing suicide just before David graduated from college. Susan is the daughter of research doctor Richard L. Landau. Select from premium Susan Axelrod of the highest quality. Axelrod worked for John Edwards' presidential campaign.He is from the Democratic political party.There is no information about his rumors in social sites. By BEN WALLACE-WELLS. About. Stay tuned to learn about the CNN senior commentators family, net worth, children, and Wiki Bio. Stay informed daily on the latest news and advice on COVID-19 from the editors at U.S. News & World Report. "Sometimes," Susan says, I wished I could put a sign on her back that said: 'Epilepsy. With the internet becoming a large part of peoples lives, he focused heavily on short videos online depicting the president as a man on the streets.. OH 44035. He was also part of Deval Patrick's successful 2006 campaign to become the first black governor of Massachusetts. Family. His passion for these efforts gained him more attention from Democrat politicians. When she fell asleep, I left to run to class. She's devoted her life to saving other kids and families from the pain Lauren and our family have known. David Axelrod (son-in-law) Richard L. Landau (1916 - June 22, 2016) was a leader in endocrinology research at the University of Chicago. She is the daughter of research doctor Richard L. Landau. No one spoke to the Axelrods of the remotest chance of a cure. Susan Landau had married David Axelrod in 1979, and they lived in Chicago, where Susan pursued an MBA at the University of Chicago and David worked as a political reporter for the Chicago Tribune. Manage Settings Lauren Axelrod, Ethan Axelrod, Michael Axelrod. Eliot A. Landau, AB'63, of Woodridge, IL, died January 4. She speaks slowly, with evident impairment but a strong Chicago accent. The couples have two sons, Michael Axelrod and Ethan Axelrod, and one daughter, Lauren Axelrod. This created a more personal relationship between the people and their future president. The medications for her seizures, as many as 10 a day, ran $1,000 a month, a devastating expense on a newspapermans salary. In April 2019, David Axelrod, wholeads the University of Chicagos Institute of Politics and his wife Susan Landau sold their mansion for $2.5 million. 6. They have also lived in South Ozone Park, NY. A fierce competitor, he had no trouble trading blows with political opponents for the past four decades. 2014 Diane Meier, '69. Fun Fact: He told the hosts of Morning Joe that he would shave his signature mustache if Obama lost Pennsylvania, Minnesota, or Michigan in the 2012 Presidential Elections. It's like little areas of her brain are waking up, Susan says. Susan Landau: Children . I phoned my mother and cried, 'This is normal, right? David attributed it to the candidates inability to seal the deal.. The . He works as the host of The Axe Files which airs on CNN. His mother, Myril Bennett works as an advertising executive at Young & Rubicam while his father Joseph Axelrod was a psychologist by profession. His father committed suicide just before he graduated. President-elect Barack Obama named Axelrod senior adviser to the president. He was born to his hardworking parents on February 22, 1955, in New York City, in the United States of America. Their first child, Lauren was born in June 1981. IE 11 is not supported. He went out to raise money for his election by selling buttons promoting his campaign. He is from a liberal Jewish family through his parents, his mother Myril Bennett was a journalist, and his father Joseph Axelrod was a psychologist. From then on, though she would continue to build her family (the Axelrods also have two sons) and support her husband's career, Susan's chief role in life would be to keep Lauren alive and functioning. David met his future wife at the University of Chicago, business student Susan Landau, the daughter of science doctor Richard L. Landau, and they were married in 1979. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Learn How rich is She in this year and how She spends money? from Emory University in 1986. The future holds promise for unlocking the mysteries of what some experts now call Epilepsy Spectrum Disorder. Our pediatrician said to give her one-quarter of an adult dose of a cold medication, and it knocked her out immediately. He snared a part-time gig writing for the neighborhood Hyde Park Herald, often scooping the big-city dailies. Susan Landau Finch. Select this result to view Susan Gail Landau's phone number, address, and more. https://t.co/xvyRnsFfYk, David Axelrod (@davidaxelrod) June 30, 2020. Susan Landau's age as of November 2020 is 66 years of age. 2. Balancing free speech on difficult topics that some might find offensive can be tricky to navigate, but it is essential to a democracy, said Axelrod, who still calls himself an idealist. The philosophy permeates the IOP and is reflected not just by invited speakers like Cotton, but also by the IOPs board of advisers (which includes such stalwart conservatives as commentator William Kristol and former Republican National Committee chair Ed Gillespie). But he also discussed the immigrant story he and Schiff share, which, in just a few generations, moved from the shtetl to the highest echelons of power. When he was 5, he sat perched atop a mailbox near his family's apartment and watched John F. Kennedy speak at a political rally; when he was 13, he volunteered with Robert F. Kennedy's presidential campaign. Axelrod was among the people Obama would consult before delivering his 2002 anti-war speech. The Risks Posed by New Wiretapping Technologies, "Security and Conflict Resolution: Susan Landau", "Cybersecurity Bill Would Shift Power Away From NSA", "List of Guggenheim Fellowships awarded in 2012", "On computing Galois groups and its application to solvability by radicals", "Susan Landau Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study", "Susan Landau: Toward Perfect Internet Security", "The Book List: Computer Science Books by Women Computer Scientists", "Women of Vision awards presented at Anita Borg Institute banquet", "Keep smartphones backdoor free, urges cybersecurity expert Susan Landau", "Susan Landau, Professor of Cybersecurity Policy, to be Inducted into the Cyber Security Hall of Fame", "Apple and FBI Take Their iPhone Hacking Fight to Congress", Notices of the American Mathematical Society, full text at the Association for Women in Mathematics, Keys Under Doormats: Mandating insecurity by requiring government access to all data and communications, Internet Eavesdropping: A Brave New World of Wiretapping, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Susan_Landau&oldid=1123058328, Fellows of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, Fellows of the Association for Computing Machinery, Massachusetts Institute of Technology School of Science alumni, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0. Find Susan Axelrod stock photos and editorial news pictures from Getty Images. David Axelrod: Net Worth of Former Senior Advisor to the President. Here we are up to, the author of the New York Times best-selling memoir Believer: My forty years in Politics and political personality responsible for Barack Obamas legacy, David Axelrod. However, Lauren was diagnosed with epilepsy when she was just seven months old. He lived in a liberal Jewish home with very educated and driven parents that influenced him to pursue his passion for helping others. The couple first child Lauren was diagnosed with epilepsy at seven months of age. Christiane Amanpour CNN, Son, Husband, Health, Languages, Net worth, Poppy Harlow CNN Salary, Husband Cancer, Height, Real Name, Net worth, Van Jones CNN Salary, Age, Wife, Baby, Organisations, Net Worth. . Susan attended classes while her mother babysat. We and our partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. . Susan is a member of the board for Girls Inc. of New York City and Volunteers of America for the Greater New York Area. Susan Landau is additionally well known as the spouse of political. Those opposing voices do not speak for the vast majority of American Jews, Axelrod said, quickly pointing out that the former president received 78% of the Jewish vote in 2008 and 70% in 2012, despite the Orthodox voting bloc. The couple got married in 1979 and had their first child, a daughter, Lauren Axelrod in June 1981. He has earned this figure from her career as a journalist. In 1998, Susan and a small group of parents frustrated by their inability to protect their children from the severe impact of uncontrollable seizures joined forces to spearhead the search for a cure for epilepsy. Landau, 99, died of natural causes Nov. 3 in Montgomery Place, an assisted-living facility in Hyde Park, according to his daughter Susan Axelrod, the wife of political consultant and former Barack . Susan Axelrod didn't go looking for her career; it came knocking on her door, full force. She became mentally impaired as a result of this, yet she was still able to attend school. He holds an American nationality and white ethnicity background. Axelrod's wife, the former Susan Landau, founded Citizens United for Research in Epilepsy (CURE). They had three children, including a daughter, Lauren, who was diagnosed with epilepsy as a toddler. Strong focus on leadership . Susan received her J.D. How Old Is David Axelrod. Axelrod revealed in 2021 in a CNN op-ed that his dad suffered from severe clinical depression and mental health issues, which made him to commit suicide when Axelrod was graduating from . The little girl was at risk of falling, of drowning in the bathtub, of dying of a seizure. Her previous positions include senior staff privacy analyst at Google, distinguished engineer at Sun . There's an active role for parents and patients. Axelrod's parents separated when he was at the age of 8. In its first decade, CURE raised $9 million, funded about 75 research projects, and inspired a change in the scientific dialogue about epilepsy. . David Axelrod married his wife, Susan Landau, in 1979, two years after they both graduated from college. He is an American political analyst as well as a political operative. But at IOP, which will mark its fifth anniversary this fall, Axelrod is on a different kind of mission. He indicated that his work as Obamas main campaign strategist in 2012 will be his final political assignment. Later, on 19th February, he joined MSNBC and NBC News as a senior political analyst. When Susan Axelrod's daughter was diagnosed with uncontrollable epilepsy, she turned her anguish into action by founding a nonprofit organization to help raise awareness about the disease. David Axelrod's wife, Susan with their daughter Lauren, who had the Epilepsy (Photo:Parade). Standard text messaging rates apply. Axelrod has an estimated net worth of $1 million. Load More . While the consulting business provided the family with a more comfortable living, it also required long stretches on the road, leaving his wife to cope with crises. Axelrod earns an average salary of between $55,890 and $87,500. Axelrod met his future wife, Susan Landau, playing basketball in a coed league in Hyde Park. Related:Van Jones CNN Salary, Age, Wife, Baby, Organisations, Net Worth. When he was 5, he sat above the mailbox close by his familys flat to see John Kennedys speech at a political rally. The couple has three children together, Lauren, a daughter, and his two sons Michael Ethan Axelrod. Terms of Service apply. Axelrod married a Chicago University classmate, Susan Landau, while working at the Tribune - 'A wonderful woman,' says de Lama, 'who, I think David would say, has completed him, made him more of a . When she acted out in public, the family felt the judgment of onlookers. . The former vice president has become the Democratic front-runner with primary victories across the country. He simultaneously spearheaded Senator Paul Simons failed presidential bid. 10. As a juvenile, he was a big fan os the Kennedys. David described his early home life as very turbulent as his parents divorced when he was only eight years old. David Axelrod's wife Susan Landau possibly has a net worth of more than $5 million to $10 million but the exact figures are not available in the . Susan Landau studies the interplay between privacy, cybersecurity, and public policy. All rights reserved. Axelrod is happily married he met his wife while studying at the University of Chicago, then business student, Susan Landau. Susan Landau in California 25 people named Susan Landau found in Los Angeles-Riverside-Orange County, San Francisco-Oakland-San Jose and 6 other cities. As an undergraduate, Axelrod wrote for the Hyde Park Herald, covering politics, and earned an internship at the Chicago Tribune. He graduated from Stuyvesant High School in New York in 1972three years after Eric Holder, Barack Obama's choice for attorney general, graduated from the school. It would not be too far out there of an idea to suggest that we may see him leading someone else to their desired elected office. Jamie Rose. latest epilepsy research news, As a 5-year-old, he clambered atop a mailbox for a better view of John F. Kennedy in the final days of the 1960 presidential campaign. [21], Landau testified that making iPhones less secure would simply send terrorists and bad actors running toward options that the FBI and Congress had no control over. . Axelrod and his wife were blessed with a daughter named Lauren in June 1981. 2. His father, Joseph Axelrod, fled religious persecution in Ukraine, immigrated to America as a child and grew up to become a psychologist. I had a class one night, I was late, there was an important test, Susan recalls. David Axelrod married to Susan Landau, they married in 1979. The two lost their fathers to suicide in 1977. In addition, he became CNNs Senior Political Advisor. Susan was born on September 23, 1947 in Somerville, New Jersey to Frank and Johanna Hirschman. The truth is that the two-state solution is the pro-Israel position., Since February 2016, The Axe Files has been downloaded 16.3 million times, according to CNN. David M. Axelrod received an honorary "Doctor of Humane Letters" degree from DePaul University, on June 14, 2009. Born on New York's Lower East Side, Axelrod grew up in a middle-class Jewish household and showed a passion for politics early. Categories . If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. ";s:7:"keyword";s:20:"susan landau axelrod";s:5:"links";s:469:"Beauty And The Beast Cocktail Experience: Chicago,
Channel 7 News Boston Anchors,
Men's Brown Cole Haan Shoes,
Articles S
";s:7:"expired";i:-1;}
{{ keyword }}Leave a reply