This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
close
";s:4:"text";s:28717:"(Alternatively, a self-grading Google Drive option is available. By engaging in this exercise, students will. ? (Alternatively, a printable option is available. Its not my fault I went over my credit limit, those shoes were calling my name!. TPT empowers educators to teach at their best. Their efforts to turn the Fog Horn back on come too late, and the creature does not slow its charge. Write for yourself and celebrate writing.. Conditions. Promote active engagement with science fiction, support the development of close reading analysis skills for high school, and evaluate general reading comprehension with this bundle of resources for teaching a collection of Ray Bradbury's short stories: "Dark They Were and Golden Eyed," "All Summer in a Day," "The Fog Horn," and "There Will Come Soft Rains." Personification is the act in speech and writing of giving inanimate objects, abstract concepts, or actions human or near human characteristics. Browse Catalog Grade Level Pre-K - K 1 - 2 3 - 5 6 - 8 9 - 12 Other Subject Arts & Music English Language Arts World Language Math Science The narrator does not understand what he is trying to say, but McDunn instructs him to just wait and watch. Something went wrong, please try again later. It's exciting! It seems to recognize the light house as a lost lovethe light house with its 40-foot neck and shining light and mournful call. : 3-1/4". personification in the fog horn. Also, this pairs with several of Munch's paintings that can be compared to his life and the fictional story. The speaker loves someone she is forbidden to see. Add highlights, virtual manipulatives, and more. Another, lesser known literary device thats related to personification is chremamorphism. The president's belief in freedom of expression is recorded in a document. Assesses Vocabulary, Comprehension, and Writing skills in a compact, easy-to-use, uniform format3. The term is most often used in relation to marine transport. An answer key is included. This is called personification. Listed below are thirty examples of personification used in normal conversations: You may also see the interrogative sentence. personification in the fog horntroi star'' torain personification in the fog horn. It was published in The Saturday Evening Post. Johnny, the narrator, is incredulous, despite having seen the creature with his own eyes. The tower emitted red and white lights, as well as a "Voice," the deep cry that the Fog Horn sent out into the world. I know that because the story has a sea monster which ado not exist in real life. Here are a few common examples of using human characteristics to describe nonhuman things. Which figure of speech is used in this text? Help high school students extend beyond general reading comprehension and support the development of close reading analysis skills with this set of rigorous, text-dependent questions on the science fiction short story "The Fog Horn" by Ray Bradbury. Post author By ; Post date 5 oraciones con el verbo take en pasado; la roche posay anthelios xl ultra light . Sound Effects / fog horn. He believes that the man who created the Fog Horn wanted to create a sound that was so lonely that "whoever hears it will know the sadness of eternity and the briefness of life" (3.). Comic books became constant companions throughout his childhood. Personification can be a great way to convey a deep connection between a person and their most valuable possessions. Both personification and chremamorphism illustrate an abstract idea with relatable human qualities, adding more dimension to the story. Examples from the text: 1. Abstract concepts like nations or emotions can also be given human qualities to personify them. Includes hundreds of titles of the best in authentic childrens literature, both popular picture books and leveled readersBUNDLE and, Help high school students develop a greater understanding of how Ray Bradbury used descriptive language, characterization, setting, and various literary devices to establish an eerie mood in "The Fog Horn" that is consistent with the supernatural fiction and science fiction genres. Which figure of speech is used in this text? Yet again he resolved to refurbish it over the summer. Materials are delivered in printable Word Document and PDF formats. GradeSaver, 25 May 2015 Web. Your dashboard will track each student's mastery of each skill. Filters. 4241 Jutland Dr #202, San Diego, CA 92117. Personification not only applies to objects; other less physical things, such as forces of nature (love and death are examples), as well as animals, can be transformed through personification. Not only do we communicate with other people, but we also communicate with our environs every day. The computer devoured information all day long. The monster never came back, according to McDunn. Also, these problems use a lot of really great poetic language. )iJ`n`'z~$TaS&i-Nd-lNZ$i- W3C+CQz,wv^"z]|_d6b@r3
tjt-byAg$r{z S"w.CBNu
l6))wD5u
*$qv,l|n9u>;xcrsy{rZEdMus\_sG}I%,(|Be3aQ_FGoYj=nd`o3+fM[ZWL4CSw)G@Cf?C?t;} (3)A1S.DMsQ'b6?| S:H#jhr2>?W*iI &wyx+ V:e|N E
9Xd)%mTHpX*rsV3L&7T
u#R1v K-@[O"Q]Ln&dwC6`m4#">*] m5MN&TLh((n@U@_SeJG>[F&1 The use of personification can make a story more lively. @ ? It oozed in ungenially, to smear sooty fingers over the two elegant young people who sat inside. Answer keys for every resource are provided. ? Rather than using moments of personified connection to add subtle highlights to a scene, anthropomorphism creates an entire person out of something unexpected. (Alternatively, a printable option is available. Instead, giving human characteristics to inanimate objects illustrates the relationship between the character and the setting, and showed the reader hints of where they can expect this relationship to go. Which figure of speech is used in this text? childhood memories and, with The Fog Horn, he simply revisited his boyhood love of dinosaurs and spun. McDunn and Johnny turn off the fog horn, and in a rage, the monster destroys the lighthouse before retreating to the sea. The camera loves you. This is a common phrase heard in film and modelling industries to describe someone as being photogenic. Air Horn - Mini Fog Horn Noise Maker With Hand held Pump 2pks of 1 Air horn Can .81oz by Air Horn. -An Anticipatory Poem activity and Fun Fact Page Not affiliated with Harvard College. (supports past and present technology theme) The Fog Horn is turned off and the author chooses to emphasize what can now be heard when the technology is removed. Throughout the ages, human beings have pondered the many mysteries of the moon. Materials are delivered in printable Word Document and PDF formats. Romeo, take me somewhere we can be alone. , , 202213! , , , . forest hill collegiate institute fraser ranking; hannah cheramy height; marriage in tunisia for foreigners; connie britton haircut. Example of Simile your eyes open like the lenses of two-foot cameras The monsters eyes looked like? The trope of the sea and men who know the sea also unites both texts. Another example might to say that a man moved at a glacial pace, or that he erupted in anger. These take images from the natural world to give a new dimension to a human being. Identify and Classify Figurative Language. "Ray Bradbury: Short Stories The Fog Horn Summary and Analysis". Teacher Instructions (3 pages) Here are just a few personification examples used in poems. Text Size:swahili jokes mchongoano fareharbor boat rental. McDunn is a supporting character in "The Fog Horn." He explains the arrival of the monster and formulates theories about why it arrives at the lighthouse once a year. Materials are delivered in printable Word Document and PDF formats. ESC prepares all aspects of your claim. oceans. The rocket soared over, turned, came back, and landed in the shale meadow fifty yards from the obsidian wall. "The Elevator" The lighthouse is reconstructed with reinforced concrete and Johnny finds a new job away from the lighthouse. 8 8 8 @ @ @ @ @ @ @ $ }A h C R 6@ 9 5 \ 8 9 9 6@ . # "1eTz6hG5 XRKMJ3,syd.>\:xdj]UY}ZHR0e?s,t>q_"`]`M +ri QE04$z|FTc{ ^2T
{8bWd4dn/ xt%WuI$`@5#d8*G` 8zn5X^r?;vN|N.xI2ek$u-93QX%[1RV]5=:afofDdcd\23|T&pT#LWSbo"sk>nr None of these. "I can't describe to you how suprised I was to find out I loved her, old sport." The lighthouse horn moaned, and the sound traveled through the thick fog, reaching the sailors who were enveloped in the grayness. [7], The influence of the short story contributed to the creation of the Godzilla franchise. Personification may sound like something left behind from the Romantic era of poetry or the work of William Shakespeare, but its actually present in almost all contemporary literature, and even in our everyday speech. The reason the monster the kept coming to the lighthouse was because it thought that it had found another monster because the sound of the fog horn made the exact same sound as the monster. Quizzes with auto-grading, and real-time student data. A year later, the narrator has got a new job inland, and McDunn works in the new lighthouse, which has been built from steel-reinforced concrete. Which figure of speech is used in this text? Included are the following: a plot-based quiz, a rigorous close reading worksheet, a craft analysis activity, and answer keys. Explore 517 results for fog horn in the Pond5 Sound Effects collection. Both are based on supernatural themes and ideas. To start off, heres the definition of personification: its a literary device that assigns traditional human attributes to nonhuman things, or even objects like household items. For example, we anthropomorphized characters in many Disney movies, like the very late rabbit in Alice in Wonderland or Nemo in Finding Nemo, two animals with person-like features; or in Lumire the candelabra in Beauty and the Beast. leonardo dicaprio house address beverly hills; Personification is an excellent writing tool for establishing the setting of a story. This story articulates the basic human need of communicating with others. Symbols There are some symbols in the "Fog Horn" such as: 1st symbol: The fog horn is a symbol in the story. 2. "The Fog Horn" written by Ray Bradbury was a rather interesting short story. In over examining every fine detail of his life, Prufrock perceives himself as useless and even a waste of life. What is a Protagonist? Is he reading into the monster's actions because of his own loneliness? Lauer, Caroline. Its a literary device that takes animals or objects and portrays them as if they were actually humans. resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss thenovel. Summary In "The Fog Horn," the narrator and a man named McDunn work in a stone tower, far out from land, to alert ships passing through the fog of their proximity to land. This empathy allows the reader to realize how central the need of communication is to basic human happiness. )Students will demonstrate knowledge of the following aspects of plot:Point of viewSettingMcDunn's thoughts on the oceanA strange incident involving a million fishThe sound of the fog hornThe ch. ][4] An official comic adaptation was produced in 1993 in Topps Comics' Ray Bradbury Comics #3. 1,691 books21.1k followers. An answer key is included. These objects can be absolutely anything, from a rakish candelabra with a French accent, to an old shoe, to a copy machinebut when theyre anthropomorphized, they appear as people-like. Love is a powerful emotion, but when we are spurned by those we love, that love may turn to hate partly, as McDunn acknowledges, as a self-preservation mechanism. LZ*@DHbF2IrXDLl Dyg/Lb7QqwM-"SYU.W{V@Vj 6O 2=a,`M1i[Gt'I1 = There are many links between thesetwo similarpoems. The meaning of The Fog Horn is perhaps best summarised by McDunns assertion, after the monster has approached the fog horn, that thats life for you: someone always waiting for someone who never comes home. As McDunn goes on to say, loving something (or someone) more than it loves us can lead us to want to destroy that thing, so it cannot hurt us any more. Which figure of speech is used in this text? answer choices The lighthouse was old needed repairs. Examples of famous works that feature personification include: 1. "The Fog Horn" by Ray Bradbury Bundle for High School . "The Monkey's Paw" "The Fog Horn". They discuss how the Fog Horn sounds like a "big lonely animal crying in the night," and then McDunn proceeds to tell the narrator that at about this time of year, "something comes to visit the lighthouse" (2.) Youve probably used personification in your own writing without realizing it. Well look at a few more personification examples down below. $3.30 delivery Jan 6 - 10 . When the monster attacks the tower, McDunn and Jimmy. Included are the following: a plot-based quiz, a rigorous close reading worksheet, a craft analysis activity, and answer keys. This gives them a vivid image and brings abstract ideas to life. What does the idiom in this text suggest? To ensure quality for our reviews, only customers who have purchased this resource can review it. When It discovers that it's been deceived, the monster succombs to anger and destroys the light house. The Fog Horn analysis. He wanted his friends to realize that life is a journey and not a destination. THE FOG HORN Present By Ted&Ken Themes Noted The theme of the story is about being lonely. For example, you might say that the electricity bill glared at her accusingly, or the wind gnashed its teeth against the window. Were not expected to take these images literallythey wont think that the electricity bill has suddenly grown eyes la that creepy book in Hocus Pocus, or that the wind is actually a vengeful spirit with disconcertingly sharp fangs. On the night before it was the narrator's turn to return to land, McDunn tells him that he has something special to tell him about. -Text Dependent Story Questions and Key "Uneasy Homecoming" Made for Google Drive, this resource serves well for an independent learning opportunity, as well as for small-group discussions. According to McDunn, the monster has been waiting. There were two protagonists followed in the plot, Johnny and McDunn. The Status of Liberty is often considered a personification of the United States, while we might say that the emotion of sadness is like a lonely man hunched in a dark corner. She was his heart and soul and didn't know what to do without her. It has resources to pair a fictional story, "The Fog Horn" with an informational nonfiction on Edvard Munch. Judge Taylor looked daggers at Atticus, as if daring him to speak. Example of personification The fog horn calls Example of repetition Deeps, Deep, deep down in the deepest Deeps. -A Vocabulary Teaching Presentation Personification. Included are the following: a self-grading, plot-based quiz; a rigorous close reading worksheet; a craft analysis activity; and answer keys. The speaker has been waiting for a long time. Why can't the men take the dinosaur home as a trophy? What to expect; First visit; FAQ; Our Practice; Why? And this means that by assigning human attributes to inanimate objects, right away youre creating a connection that your reader will be able to relate to. Bradbury says that the idea for the story came from seeing the ruins of a demolished roller coaster on a Los Angeles-area beach. These papers were written primarily by students and provide critical analysis of select short stories by Ray Bradbury. The lighthouse's resonating fog horn attracts a sea monster. [2], Leonard Nimoy stated that this story was part of the inspiration behind the 1986 film Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home. Careful use of imagery is an important aspect of creating a vivid image in the minds eye. It was lonely work. Before we offer an analysis of The Fog Horn, heres a brief summary of the storys plot. The lighthouse horn moaned, and the sound traveled through the thick fog, reaching the sailors who were enveloped in the grayness. Words used in the puzzle are artificial, chauffeur, compliment, corroborate, corruption, dejection, exasperate, extravaganza, fender, foghorn, forlorn, grail, holocaust, humidor, incorruptible, leash, luxury, malice, melancholy, mus, Promote active engagement with science fiction, support the development of close reading analysis skills for high school, and evaluate general reading comprehension with this bundle of resources for teaching a collection of Ray Bradbury's short stories: "Dark They Were and Golden Eyed," "All Summer in a Day," "The Fog Horn," and "There Will Come Soft Rains." McDunns statement towards the end of The Fog Horn, that the monster had learnt we cannot love anything too much in this life, is also clearly meant to be applied not just to this primeval creature from the Deeps but also, by extension, to all human beings. This is in fact the third time the monster has visited the lighthouse: he has been attracted by the same fog horn on the same night for the last two years. the foghorn the evening mist the red and white lights human voices Question 2 120 seconds Q. Notice how the personification examples above didnt actually communicate any hard details about the settingthe rust on the hinges of the doors, the yellowing flyers stuck to the walls, etc. Print, edit, or complete this activity online! The Fog Horn is another variation on this moral theme which emphasises the importance of connection and company. * Develop a greater understanding of how Ray Bradbury used descriptive language, characterization, setting, and various literary devices to establish an eerie mood that is consistent with the supernatural fiction and science fiction genres. Luckily it was a soft drink. A writers word choice when writing personification can lend entirely different moods and tones to the imagery of a story. 58. -A 3 page vocabulary activity with key Meanwhile, a film with a similar theme of prehistoric sea monster was being shot under the working title of Monster from Beneath the Sea. As the monster called out, it made a sound eerily similar to the sound of the Fog Horn. All materials are delivered in printable Word Document and PDF formats. The monster, meanwhile, hasnt reappeared, with McDunn convinced that it has gone away because it learnt you cant love anything too much in life. * Apply knowledge of sonic literary devices including consonance and assonance The plot in the thirteenth episode of Pokmon, "Mystery at the Lighthouse" (1997), is based on this short story. Chremamorphism is the inverse of personification: it ascribes non-human characteristics to a human (or humanoid) entity. This is a lesson for a Intermediate/Senior Short Story unit. The dinosaur is a symbol for loneliness, the human basic need for communication, and destruction. "The Moose and the Sparrow" Conspiring with him how to load and bless, With fruit the vines that round the thatch-eves run. When we come to the end of each poem, we realise that they both have a similar structure in the way that they begin by describing the distressful sound of the fog horns, describe the reactions to it and end rounding the poems off with repeating the idea of the unpleasant sound. Examples of personification in everyday speech, Examples of personification in literature, Personification makes your story come alive. Oscar's '64 Impala groaned as he turned the ignition. What does the personification in this text suggest? Materials are made for Google Drive. McDunn tells Johnny that the lighthouse tower has a fog horn which makes a noise that sounds like an animal. They work in a lighthouse at night and the horn alerts all the ships in danger . Giving the sun "golden arms" creates a vivid image of . 'QCP5%lrJj:jS:3 r:='2)\7kKMPl/Z4,UxdHP$A_LSD 8$~lU * Articulate what is stated in the text explicitly and implicitly * Identify several examples of personification and/or anthropomorphism in the narrative * Identify several textual details that contribute to a sense of isolation * Discern the intended meaning of figurative language . A heart can't . Sidney has a lot on his plate: he is attending college, has a full-time job as a waiter, and volunteers at the animal shelter. One of the most humane and humanist features of Bradburys fiction is his sense of man as a deeply social being, who needs human contact, companionship, friendship, and communion with others. This is what makes the dystopian police state of his story The Pedestrian (which, perhaps for this reason, immediately followed The Fog Horn in The Golden Apples of the Sun) so repellent: it is a world in which people have been conditioned to shun the streets and the night life of the city in favour of vegetating in front of the television every evening in their tomblike homes. In this example we see how the protagonist projects human characteristics onto her old textbooks, projecting some of her feelings onto them. Promote active engagement with fiction, support the development of close reading analysis skills for high school, and evaluate general reading comprehension with this bundle of resources for teaching the science fiction short story "The Fog Horn" by Ray Bradbury. How to Bridge the Ordinary and the Extraordinary, Literary Devices List: 33 Main Literary Devices with Examples, What Is an Antagonist? Question 9 60 seconds Q. * Cite textual evidence in support of inferences and claims The story, which is about a lighthouse whose foghorn emits a noise which attracts the attention of a primeval dinosaur living miles below the ocean, contains a number of key themes of Bradburys work, especially in its depiction of technology and the need for connection and companionship. qaGUAavL>! Which figure of speech is used in this text? There are 28 words/clues in the puzzle. personification in the fog hornteenage wellness retreat. IT TRAVELS IT SEEKS. )By comple, Short stories that are perfect for a suspense and mystery unit! By using many poetic devices including repetition, personification, and imagery Eliot drives readers to feel the painful reality of Prufrock's life. THE FOG HORN STIRS UP ECHOES OF ANCIENT MEMORIES. Personification is a powerful and widely-used literary tool for several reasons. * Make logical inferences about character motivations * Write with clarity and precision After promising to work on my campaign for class president, he decided to support my opponent. In the short story "The Fog Horn" by Ray Bradbury the theme "loneliness can be taken for granted" is best shown through the actions of McDunn and the creature in the sea. SO, STIRS A YEARING. Type: Multiple-Choice Category: Figurative Language Level: Grade 10 Score: 11 Author: zz1989 Last Modified: 10 years ago View all questions by zz1989. - 2 ,-. They decide to experiment and turn off the Fog Horn. 'The Signalman' taken from Charles Dickens' 'Mugby Junction' was written 1866 whereas 'The Foghorn' was written almost a century later. The monster is all alone, spurned by an ever-changing world, but the man-made fog horn (unusually in a Ray Bradbury story) is a piece of technology which represents a call for communion and coming together. For example, if you said that the branches quaked fearfully against the coming storm, most readers can imagine what that looks like because they know what it is to quake fearfully against something thats headed their way. Which figure of speech is used in this text? It looks like nothing was found at this location. The fog horn blew. Unfortunately, the wild blueberries we picked were as sweet as vinegar. Gift a membership upgrade & buy gift certificates, Get a professional online writing portfolio at Writerfolio, Free, liberated ebooks for the true book lover. Fog Horn 10. The story was reprinted in various collections including the 1953 publication The Golden Apples of the Sun, the Japanese publications The Fog Horn & Other Stories in 1979 and The Fog Horn and Other Stories in 1981 (both editions were published in English also), and finally Dinosaur Tales in 1983. Use these sma Subjects: Whats the difference between personification vs. chremamorphism? A) It hears the call of the foghorn B) It visits every day C) It is lost during the storm. Carl Sandburg's Fog poem features beautiful images of cats, paws, the city, and a harbor; it includes different levels of coloring--easier, as well as more intricate, coloring pages). It is as if it thinks the Fog Horn is a long lost friend, companion, or lover. The two men head down into the cellar and hide there while the tower collapses, bringing an end to the noise of the fog horn. Such a life is not living, Bradbury says, unless we call it a living death. It especially helps them with items and vocabulary they are not familiar with. such as myna bird, fog horn, rollaway bed, tiller.. etc. THE FOG HORN by Ray Bradbury OUT there in the cold water, far from land, we waited every night for the coming of the fog, and it came, and we oiled the brass machinery and lit the fog light up in the stone tower. Now the only sound is that of the monsters wailing lament. Who do we seek for companionship in our everyday life? We are in constant communication with the people around us, and it is very difficult when we are in extended isolation. Ray Bradbury: Short Stories essays are academic essays for citation. Or fastest delivery Jan 5 - 9 . With this in mind, one wonders if the monster really believed the fog horn was another monster, or does he know it is not a monster yet returns for the comfort of its sound? The Fog Horn Teaching Resources | Teachers Pay Teachers Browse the fog horn resources on Teachers Pay Teachers, a marketplace trusted by millions of teachers for original educational resources. Puzzle (with solution) based on Chapter 8 of The Great Gatsby.Although students see this as a fun activity, it is an active learning task. The sun glared down from the sky. In this example, the speaker is personifying the sun to give a feeling of antagonism and discomfort on a hot summers day. )By engaging in this exercise, students willArticulate what is stated in the text explicitly and impl. Your conscience can lead you around in circles. Are you getting the free resources, updates, and special offers we send out every week in our teacher newsletter? The man saw her as his hero. Promote active engagement with fiction, support the development of close reading analysis skills for high school, and evaluate general reading comprehension with this bundle of resources for teaching the science fiction short story "The Fog Horn" by Ray Bradbury. Charles Dickens is also a person whose name is known throughout the English speaking world . Recommendation Letter from Dr. Ehtisham Iqbal, Second Annual Women of Distinction Awards, Lucy Viggiano Feature in Valley Stream Herald. Tes Global Ltd is . These personified images communicate something new and more complex than simply describing the grey doors and empty walls of a nondescript building. The car complained as she started the rusty engine. In this brief sentence, we can immediately imagine the sound of a tired car putting up a fight as it gets ready to work. Materials are made for Google Drive. This allows writers to create life and motion within inanimate objects, animals, and even abstract ideas by . The sailors were complaining because they were lost. Get started for FREE Continue. "The Million Year Picnic" Summary and Analysis, "The Last Night of the World" Summary and Analysis. Also included in:"The Fog Horn" by Ray Bradbury Quiz and Close Reading Bundle (Printable), Also included in:Grade 9/10/11: Complete Short Story Unit, Also included in:Short Stories for High School English Language Arts Quiz Bundle, Also included in:Short Stories for High School - Craft Analysis Activities for Google Drive, Also included in:"The Fog Horn" by Ray Bradbury Quiz and Close Reading Bundle for Google Drive, Also included in:The Great Gatsby - Bundle of Vocabulary Crossword Puzzles. Which figure of speech is used in this text? Ray Bradbury. Imagery: it's desribe how the ground looked and sounded as their feet touched it. O The personification emphasizes the distressed and melancholy mood of the speaker The simile compares the sound of the foghorn to a nightmare. ";s:7:"keyword";s:31:"personification in the fog horn";s:5:"links";s:217:"Ottolenghi Tomato Salad Ginger,
Articles P
";s:7:"expired";i:-1;}
{{ keyword }}Leave a reply